How to reach out to people who unfollowed a competitor

Identify and message leads who stopped engaging with your competitors on LinkedIn by spotting the engagement gap and offering a better alternative.

Get started

Short answer

You can't track the exact moment someone clicks unfollow because LinkedIn keeps that data private. Instead, find people who commented on a competitor's posts months ago but have been silent recently. This gap suggests they're no longer getting value, which is the right time to offer a different approach.

Identify the engagement gap

You won't get a notification when someone unfollows a company page. LinkedIn doesn't publish that list, and it doesn't tell the company who stopped following. So you have to look for behavioral signals instead. The strongest signal is the engagement gap: the space between when a lead was an active advocate and when they went silent.

People currently commenting on a competitor's posts are usually satisfied or still in the early phase of using the product. They're hard to move. People who used to be vocal but stopped are often the ones who hit a product failure, a pricing change, or a drop in service quality. They may still follow the page, but they've stopped engaging.

To find these people, scroll back through a competitor's post history from six to twelve months ago. List the people who asked deep questions or shared success stories. If they haven't liked or commented on that competitor's content in 90 days, they've entered the gap. Keep the lead if they still hold the job title that makes them a fit.

A simple spreadsheet works. Add the person's name, company, the post they commented on, the date of their last comment, and the exact phrase they used. That phrase becomes your hook later. You don't need a big list. Twenty well-chosen leads beat two hundred random names.

Active leads

  • Commenting on posts this week
  • Tagging the competitor in praise
  • Sharing recent product updates

Gapped leads

  • Commented frequently six months ago
  • Zero interactions in the last 90 days
  • Still holds the target job title

Audit the competitor's recent failures

Once you have a list of gapped leads, you need to know why they likely left. Don't ask them yet. Instead, audit the competitor's public failures. The goal is to find the friction point that made a happy user go quiet.

Go to the competitor's Posts tab and look for threads with high comment volumes but low response rates from the company. Look for posts where the company promised a new feature or a fix for a known bug. Read the comments from the people on your list. These are the friction points.

Pay attention to the language users use. If you see phrases like 'still waiting,' 'doesn't work as advertised,' or 'looking for an alternative,' you've found the specific pain point to use in your outreach. Write down the exact words. Your message should sound like a person who understands the problem, not a marketer who read a summary.

Check whether the company replied. A public complaint with no answer is a stronger signal than a complaint that got resolved. If the company answered with a generic response, that also tells you something. The lead may have felt ignored.

  1. 1

    Scan the posts tab

    Filter by the competitor's recent posts and look for high-engagement threads.

  2. 2

    Find the friction point

    Identify posts where users complain about a specific feature or a lack of updates.

  3. 3

    Extract the vocabulary

    Write down the exact words users use to describe their frustration so you can mirror them in your messages.

Build the outreach angle

The message should reference the topic they used to care about. That proves you aren't sending a mass blast. You remember the conversation they had in public, and you're writing about that subject.

The hook should mention the old topic without naming the competitor. The pivot acknowledges that the industry has moved forward or that the old way of solving that problem is now too slow. Keep the pivot short. One sentence is enough.

End with a low-friction offer. Don't ask for a demo. Ask for a short chat to share how you handle that specific pain point differently. This makes the note feel like a peer asking about a shared problem.

Here is a simple example. The lead complained about reporting on the Acme page. Your message mentions reporting, not Acme. The lead sees a person who knows the problem. You see a lead who already described the problem in public.

Example

  1. You

    Hi Sarah, I saw your comments a while back about automated reporting on the Acme page. I'm curious if you're still finding that a challenge in your workflow?

  2. Prospect

    Honestly, it's been a nightmare. The feature they promised never actually launched for my tier.

  3. You

    That's a common frustration we've heard. We built our reporting to handle that specific gap. Would you be open to a 15-minute chat next Tuesday to see how we do it?

The outreach sequence

Structure your sequence to build trust before you make the ask. If you jump straight into the competitor's failure, you risk sounding aggressive or desperate. Start with a connection request that focuses on the industry and the topic.

Once they accept, you have permission to send a longer message. This is where you introduce the gap in the competitor's value proposition. Keep it specific. Mention the problem they described, not a generic claim about your product.

If they don't reply to the first message, don't push the product again. Instead, send a specific example of a client who switched to you for the exact reason the lead was frustrated. This provides social proof that your alternative is real.

If they still don't reply, stop. A third message to someone who never answered is not persistence. It's noise. Move on and keep the lead in a later sequence if their situation changes.

  1. 1

    The connection request

    Send a request mentioning you saw their old thoughts on [Topic] and wanted to connect with others in [Industry].

  2. 2

    The gap message

    Wait for acceptance, then send a message focusing on the specific failure you identified in the competitor's audit.

  3. 3

    The proof follow-up

    Send a short case study or a one-sentence result from a client who left that competitor for your service.

Avoid mentioning the competitor by name in the very first connection request. It can trigger a defensive response. Wait until the second message.

What to do when they reply

When someone replies, ask one question about the old problem. Don't pitch immediately. If they say they're still using the competitor, ask what would need to change for them to consider an alternative. If they say they left, ask what made them switch. The answer tells you whether the lead is worth a call.

If they ask for a call, send a link and confirm the time. If they ask for pricing, give a range and ask what they're trying to solve. If they say they're not interested, thank them and close the loop. A clean no is better than a follow-up that ignores the answer.

Keep the conversation in one thread. Don't move them to email unless they ask. The reply is the strongest signal you have, and the thread keeps the context in one place.

Doing this with Kinlead

Finding these gaps manually takes a lot of scrolling. The Steal Customers agent watches competitor company pages and optional founder or employee profiles, reads the comments on their recent posts, and turns commenters who look like buyers into leads. Each lead keeps the post URL, what the post was about, and what they commented.

You can use a sales playbook to let AI draft messages from your goal and tone. Outreach runs from your own LinkedIn account at a human pace, one action every 5 minutes. You can review and edit queued messages on the Actions page before they send.

Paste this job

Prompt for Sales Playbook: 'Target leads who commented on [Competitor] posts about [Pain Point]. Tone: Professional but empathetic. Goal: Book a 15-minute chat to discuss our alternative approach to [Pain Point].'

Frequently asked questions

Related

Get started with Kinlead

Prefer markdown? How to reach out to people who unfollowed a competitor.md