How to handle LinkedIn leads that aren't a perfect fit
Stop deleting LinkedIn leads that fall just short of your profile. Use a peer conversation to turn them into referral sources, with a template you can copy.
Get startedShort answer
Don't delete leads that fall just short of your profile. Move them into a separate group, ask about their work instead of pitching, and ask for a specific referral once they've replied a few times. The goal is a name, not a meeting.
Deciding who counts as a borderline lead
Most teams sort a lead list into people who fit and people who don't, then delete the second pile. That throws away the part of the list that already knows your buyer. Someone who can't sign off on your product this quarter might sit three desks from the person who can.
A borderline lead clears most of your criteria and fails one. The title is right but the company is too small. The company fits but the role is adjacent. The region is wrong even though the team clearly has the problem. They understand the work well enough to have an opinion on it, which is more than most of a cold list can offer.
Treat them as a peer. A pitch tells someone who already knows they aren't a buyer that you didn't read their profile. A question about their work gets a reply, and often a name you didn't have that morning.
Run the sort before you write any messages. Go through the list and put each person in one of three buckets based on how close they are, not on how much you like the company. Ten minutes of sorting stops you sending a pitch to someone who was never going to buy and could have introduced you to three people who would.
Deleting on one mismatch
- Wrong company size: delete
- Adjacent title: delete
- Right company, wrong region: delete
Sorting by distance from the profile
- Fits everything: normal sales sequence
- Right role, smaller company: peer conversation
- Right industry, adjacent role: referral conversation
What to write first when they can't buy
Your first message has one job, which is to get a reply. A meeting is a later problem, and asking for one now tells them you're running a sequence.
Leave your product out of the first two messages. Mention a detail from their profile or a post they wrote, then ask something they can answer in a sentence. People answer questions about their own work far more often than questions about an offer that isn't for them.
Skip the compliments. 'Love your content' is noise and everyone gets it. Point at a specific detail and ask what it means.
The people most likely to answer are the ones who write publicly about their work. If someone posts about hiring, tooling or process, they've already told you what they'll talk about.
Example
- You
Hi Sarah, your post on async workflows in design agencies stuck with me. The agencies I talk to keep saying quality went up and onboarding doubled. Which of those are you seeing more of?
- Prospect
Onboarding, definitely. We've started pairing new designers with a senior for the first month just to keep the work consistent.
- You
That's the part nobody writes about. How long does the pairing last before they're on their own?
- Prospect
About four weeks. After that they're fine.
- You
Good to know. That matches what two other agency leads told me. Thanks for the detail, it's useful.
Nothing in that exchange mentions a product or a calendar link, and it still does real work: it proves they'll talk to you, shows how they think about the problem, and gives you something to answer next time. Most people stop after one message because they asked for a meeting.
Turning the conversation into a referral
After two or three exchanges, ask. A vague request like 'let me know if you know anyone' hands them a job. A specific request they can answer or ignore in ten seconds is a favor, not homework.
Say why you're asking them and not someone else. They sit in a role that sees the problem across a lot of companies, or they used to work somewhere that fits your profile.
Give something back that costs you something: an introduction, a benchmark from other conversations, a read on what's changing in their market.
Expect a no. Most people won't have a name ready, and that's fine. The conversation still leaves you with someone who knows what you do, which is the whole point of keeping borderline leads around.
- 1
Have one real exchange first
Ask a question about their work and reply with something useful. A single message that ends in a pitch is not an exchange.
- 2
Name the problem and the role
Say what the person you want is dealing with and what their job title usually is. Vague referrals rarely arrive.
- 3
Make it easy to say no
Add that nobody coming to mind is fine. It lowers the cost of replying and keeps the relationship intact.
- 4
Close the loop
Tell them what happened with the introduction, even if it went nowhere. They'll remember that you didn't disappear after getting the name.
Paste this job
Hi {{first_name}}, one thing before I let you get back to your week. I'm talking to ops leads at agencies in the 40 to 80 person range about {{problem}}. You've worked across a few of them, so you'd know better than me: is anyone in your network dealing with this right now? If nobody comes to mind, no problem at all. I'll send over what I've learned from the last few conversations either way.Keeping borderline leads in their own group
Don't run borderline leads through the same sequence as buyers. You'll either push too hard and lose the relationship, or move too slowly with people who were ready to talk.
A couple of follow-ups is enough for a peer conversation. If they go quiet, leave them in the group and come back in a month with something worth reading, not a reminder that you exist.
Keep a third group for people who have sent you a referral. They're the most useful non-customers you have. Send them news before you announce it publicly, ask what they think of a change you're making, and don't pitch them again.
Name the groups so you can tell them apart at a glance. 'Fits the profile', 'knows the problem' and 'sent a name' work better than 'tier 1, 2, 3', because the label tells you what the next message should be.
Fits the profile
- Group
- Book a call
- Goal
- Direct, about their problem
- Tone
- Follow up until they reply or decline
Borderline
- Group
- Stay in touch
- Goal
- Curious, peer to peer
- Tone
- Occasional check-ins with something new
Sent a referral
- Group
- Keep the relationship
- Goal
- Grateful, low key
- Tone
- News before you announce it
When they tell you they can't buy
Often they'll say it out loud. 'We're too small for this' or 'that's not my area'. That's the best thing that can happen in the thread, because the boundary is on the table and you can ask around it without pretending.
What you do next decides whether they help you. Arguing with the boundary, or saying you work with companies their size too, reads as a pitch. Accepting it and asking one question keeps the conversation going.
Keep a note of what they told you. When someone changes jobs or their team grows past the size where your product makes sense, you'll want to know, and that note is the difference between a warm re-open and a cold message.
Pushing past the boundary
- We actually do work with smaller teams, happy to show you how.
- No worries, I'll check back in a few months.
- Understood. Who else should I talk to?
Accepting it, then asking
- That makes sense. Out of curiosity, does anyone own this at companies your size, or does it land on whoever notices first?
- Fair enough. Different question: who in your network is running a team twice your size and dealing with this?
- Understood. I'll send you what I'm seeing from the larger teams, might be useful when you get there.
The first strong reply asks for information and is useful even if they never refer anyone. The second asks once, clearly, after they've shown they'll talk to you.
Doing this with Kinlead
Kinlead scores each lead from 0 to 100 against the customer you describe and doesn't keep leads below the fit line. That default suits a sales campaign. For peer conversations, keep a separate lead group for the people you want to stay in touch with and import them from a CSV of LinkedIn profile URLs, so they sit in that group whatever their score.
Point a campaign at that group and give it a playbook that describes the conversation you want: their opinion, not a meeting. Connection requests can carry an AI-written note under 200 characters that opens with why that person became a lead, which reads better than a generic greeting.
Set that campaign to hand the conversation to you at the first reply. Kinlead sends at most one action every 5 minutes per LinkedIn account, inside the daily limits and send window you set, so the pace stays slow enough for this kind of thread.
Hand-off mode is the setting for peer conversations. In the AI reply modes, replies send on their own with no approval step.
Frequently asked questions
Related
Get started with Kinlead
Prefer markdown? How to handle LinkedIn leads that aren't a perfect fit.md