How to reach out to former prospects at a new company
Reconnect with former prospects who changed jobs using templates, timing advice and follow-up tactics that turn old conversations into new account entries.
Get startedShort answer
Reach out to former prospects who moved companies by leading with their career change and connecting previous conversations to their new role. Wait a few weeks after they start, then ask whether the old problem exists in the new company. Use the trust from the first conversation to skip the cold start at a new account.
Identify the move
You don't need a complex system to find people who moved. The best data is on their LinkedIn profile, but you have to look for gaps in your current lists. Start with the people you actually spoke to. Skip the rest of the database for now.
Review closed-lost or stalled leads from six to eighteen months ago. These people know your name and understand your value, which makes the second attempt easier than a cold start. A prospect who ignored you at a company with no budget may be the person with budget at the next company.
Check the start date on the new role. A move that started within the last ninety days is a good signal. If the move is older than six months, they likely have their tool stack set and the window is smaller. You can still reach out, but expect a colder conversation.
- 1
Audit old lead lists
Go through your CRM or spreadsheets for people you had a real conversation with but didn't close. Focus on those who were a good fit but lacked budget or timing.
- 2
Verify the transition
Visit their profile and check the experience section for a new company title that started within the last ninety days.
- 3
Filter by past company
Use the LinkedIn search bar to filter by Past Company using the names of your target accounts to see where they landed.
Decide who is worth contacting
Not every job change deserves a message. A prospect who took a new role at a company that cannot buy your product is a waste of a touch. Use three filters before you write anything: fit, timing and memory.
Fit means the new company matches your customer profile. Timing means they have been in seat long enough to see the problems but short enough that they are still open to outside input. Memory means they would recognize your name or the project you discussed.
If they moved to a much larger company, they may have less control over purchasing. If they moved to a smaller company, they may have more budget authority but less time. Adjust the message to the new company and the new role. A message that worked at a 500-person company can sound wrong at a 20-person startup.
The outreach strategy
Avoid sending a generic congratulations message. People get a lot of these the day they update their profile and will ignore anything that looks like a notification.
The message should do two jobs: acknowledge the move and test whether the old problem exists in the new role. Use a specific detail from your last conversation. If you cannot remember one, look at your notes or the old email thread before you write.
Do not congratulate them in the first sentence and ask for a meeting in the second. Give them room to say the new company is different, the problem is solved, or they are not ready to talk. A short question gets a better reply than a paragraph about your product.
Generic and automated
- Congrats on the new role! Hope all is well.
- Exciting news about the new job. Let me know if you want to catch up.
- I saw you joined Acme Corp. I'd love to show you how our tool can help you succeed there.
Personal and contextual
- Congrats on the move to Acme. When we spoke at Northwind, you mentioned that manual reporting was a nightmare. Is that still a priority for you in the new role?
- Saw you joined Acme. I remember our chat about scaling the SDR team. I'm not sure if the setup there is different, but I'd love to hear how the transition is going.
- Congrats on the new role. I've been working with a few people at Acme on their lead flow. Since we already discussed this at Northwind, I thought I'd reach out.
Message templates
Choose your tone based on how close you were. If you had a deep discovery call, be direct. If you only had a brief exchange, keep it low pressure.
The first message should be short enough to read on a phone. Put the context in one sentence, ask one question, and stop. Do not attach a calendar link in the first message.
Example
- You
Congrats on the move to Acme, Sarah. When we spoke at Northwind, you mentioned that lead routing was a major bottleneck for your team. Is that something you're inheriting at Acme, or is the setup different there?
- Prospect
Thanks! It's actually a bit of a mess here too, though the tools are different. I'm still figuring out how things work here.
- You
That's usually how it goes. I'm not looking to pitch you while you're still unpacking your desk, but once you've settled in, I'd love to share how we handled that for the team at Northwind.
Keep the first message under 100 words. Prospects are overwhelmed with onboarding and won't read a long letter.
Handling the conversation
Not every move is an immediate opportunity. Some prospects are in a listening mode for the first ninety days and aren't authorized to buy software yet.
Stay top of mind so you're the first person they call when they decide to fix a problem. If they don't remember you, provide a specific anchor to your last conversation. Mention the company, the project and the month if you have it.
Ask who owns the problem now if they say it is not their area. A referral to the right person inside the new company is still a win. Log the name and use it in your next message.
Forgot who you are
- Prospect response
- Remind them of a specific project or date.
- Your strategy
- We spoke last October about the Q4 planning project at Northwind.
Too busy to talk
- Prospect response
- Offer a specific follow up date.
- Your strategy
- Totally understand. I'll check back in 30 days once you've had a chance to settle in.
Not a fit here
- Prospect response
- Ask for the internal owner of that problem.
- Your strategy
- Makes sense. Who is currently handling the lead routing at Acme?
New company uses a competitor
- Prospect response
- Ask what they like and what is missing.
- Your strategy
- That makes sense. What does the team wish the current setup did better?
Follow up and track the move
Put every mover in a simple list with three fields: old company, new company, and the date they started. That list becomes a small pipeline you can work without rebuilding it each week.
Set a follow-up for two to three weeks after the first message. If they replied but were not ready, ask for a specific month to check back. If they did not reply, send one short note with a new reason to talk, then stop.
A follow-up should add a new fact or a useful resource instead of repeating the first message. Share a short outline, a relevant example from their old company, or a question about how the new team handles the problem.
- 1
Log the move
Record the old company, new company, start date and the last conversation you had with them.
- 2
Set a reminder
Pick a date two to three weeks out. Put it on your calendar with the context you need to write a useful message.
- 3
Send one useful follow-up
Share a resource or ask a question that shows you remember their situation. Do not repeat the first message.
- 4
Close the loop
If there is no reply after the second message, move them to a quarterly check-in list and stop active outreach.
One follow-up is enough. If there is no reply after the second message, move them to a quarterly check-in list.
Paste this job
Hi Sarah, circling back now that you've had a few weeks at Acme. When we spoke at Northwind, lead routing was the bottleneck. If that is still on your list, I can send the one-page outline we used there. If not, no problem.
Doing this with Kinlead
Once you have the profile URLs of people who moved, import a CSV into a lead group. Kinlead scores each lead from 0 to 100 against the customer profile you describe, and leads below the fit line are not kept.
Point a campaign at that group. Outreach runs from your own LinkedIn account through Unipile, and Kinlead never stores your LinkedIn password. Each account sends at most one action every 5 minutes, inside the daily invite and message limits you set and inside a send window in the lead's time zone.
Set the campaign to hand the conversation to you at the first reply. Queued messages can be read and edited on the Actions page before they send, and any campaign can be paused. You can book a demo to see the lead groups and reply handling.
Frequently asked questions
Related
Get started with Kinlead
Prefer markdown? How to reach out to former prospects at a new company.md