# LinkedIn lead scoring criteria checklist
> Stop wasting time on bad prospects. Learn how to build a weighted scoring system and a fit line to identify B2B leads who can actually buy your product.
- HTML: https://getkinlead.com/linkedin-lead-scoring-criteria-checklist
- Markdown: https://getkinlead.com/linkedin-lead-scoring-criteria-checklist.md

**Short answer:** To score LinkedIn leads, replace gut feelings with a weighted point system based on job title, company size, and industry keywords. Set a minimum point threshold, known as a fit line, to automatically discard anyone who lacks the authority or budget to buy.

## Define your ideal customer profile

Searching for a broad title like Director of Marketing is too vague. You need a profile based on people who already pay you. Look at your current customers who pay on time and get the most value from your product. If you don't have customers yet, look at your competitors' customers.

Look for patterns in three areas: authority, company scale, and specific language. Authority is the title that signs the check. Scale is the employee count where your product is a necessity. Language is the specific phrasing people use in their about sections to describe their problems.

A common mistake is targeting the person who uses the tool instead of the person who pays for it. The user might love your product, but the buyer cares about the ROI. Your scoring system must prioritize the buyer's traits over the user's traits.

1. **List top job titles.** Find the three most common titles of your best customers. Be specific. Use VP of Sales or Head of Revenue instead of just Sales.
2. **Identify the company size range.** Find the employee count where your product provides the most value. A 11 to 50 employee company has different needs than a 500 person organization.
3. **Extract profile keywords.** Write down five keywords found in the profiles of buyers. Look for phrases like series A, digital transformation, or scaling operations.
4. **Map the decision process.** Determine if your buyer ever needs approval from another department. If a CFO must sign off, you may need to score leads for both the champion and the financial approver.

## Build your scoring weights

Assign a numerical value to your traits. Not all attributes are equal. A perfect job title is a stronger indicator of a buyer than a general industry match. Use a 100 point scale to keep the math simple.

The goal is a system where a lead must hit a specific number to be a fit. This stops you from picking leads just because they have a professional headshot or went to the same college as you. It removes the emotional bias that leads to wasting time on low-probability prospects.

When assigning weights, consider the cost of a false positive. If sending a message to a wrong lead costs you nothing but a few minutes, you can be more lenient. If you are spending hours on personalized research, your weights must be stricter.

| | Attribute | Perfect Match | Partial Match |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Job Title | 50 points | 20 points |
| Company Size | 30 points | 10 points |
| Profile Keywords | 5 points per keyword | 0 points |
| Industry | 20 points | 10 points |

## Set your fit line

The fit line is the minimum score a lead needs before you spend any time on them. If you have a huge list and a small team, move the line higher. If you are a founder doing the outreach, you can set it lower, but you still need a floor to avoid people who cannot buy.

Divide leads into three buckets based on these scores. This tells you who gets a personalized video, who gets a standard message, and who gets ignored. High scorers get the most manual effort because they have the highest probability of closing.

A fit line prevents the common trap of chasing the wrong people just to feel productive. It is better to have 10 leads that actually fit your profile than 100 leads that look okay on the surface but lack the budget or authority to move forward.

**Gut feeling scoring**

- They work in tech, so they probably need this.
- They have 500 connections, so they are influential.
- Their profile looks professional.

**Weighted scoring**

- Score 85: VP of Sales, 20 employees, mentions scaling.
- Score 60: Sales Manager, 100 employees, wrong industry.
- Score 30: Marketing Intern, 10 employees, no keywords.

> If a lead scores below 50 points, they are not a lead. They are a profile. Do not add them to your outreach list.

## Test your criteria on 20 profiles

Your first weights will be wrong. You might give too many points to industry and not enough to job title. Fix this by running a manual test on a small sample of real profiles from LinkedIn.

Find 20 people who look like a great fit. Score them using your table. If your gut says a person is a 10/10 lead but your system gives them a 40, your weights are off. You need to identify which attribute you undervalued.

Do this test twice. Once with people you think are perfect, and once with people you think are barely acceptable. If the barely acceptable people are scoring higher than the perfect ones, your scoring logic is flawed and needs a reset.

1. **Gather a sample.** Use LinkedIn search to find 20 profiles that look like potential buyers.
2. **Calculate total scores.** Apply your weights to each profile and sum the points.
3. **Adjust the weights.** Compare the score to your intuition. If a perfect lead scores low, increase the points for the attributes they have.
4. **Verify the floor.** Check if any obviously bad leads still passed your fit line. If so, increase the minimum threshold.

## Refine based on reply data

Once you start sending messages, the data will tell you if your scoring is actually working. Track who replies and, more importantly, who books a meeting. If you are getting replies from people with low scores, you might have missed a key attribute in your ICP.

If you are getting high scores but zero replies, the problem is either your message or your fit line is too narrow. You might be targeting people who are too senior to care about the day to day pain your product solves.

Keep a log of the profiles that say no. If five people with the same title all tell you they don't have the budget, lower the score for that title or raise the company size requirement.

- **you:** Hi Sarah, saw you're scaling the sales team at Acme. Most VPs I talk to struggle with lead quality during growth. Is that a priority for you?
- **them:** We actually handle this internally with a custom tool, so we're all set.
- **you:** Makes sense. If you ever find the custom tool is too slow to maintain, I'll be around.

## Doing this with Kinlead

Kinlead automates finding and scoring these leads. Instead of adding up points by hand, you describe your customer or provide your website and the system finds people who match. This removes the manual labor of auditing every profile.

Each lead is scored from 0 to 100. You set the fit line and any lead below it is removed. This ensures your outreach only goes to high-fit prospects. Leads are kept in lead groups, and any campaign can point at any group.

The system uses LinkedIn's standard search, so you don't need a Sales Navigator seat. It sends at a human pace, with at most one action every 5 minutes, and respects the daily limits and send windows you set.

- Finds leads based on your website or a customer description.
- Scores leads 0 to 100 and removes those below the fit line.
- Keeps high-fit leads in organized lead groups for campaigns.
- Allows leads to be exported to or imported from CSVs of LinkedIn URLs.

> You can see how Kinlead handles scoring and lead groups by booking a [demo](/demo).

## Related

- [AI lead scoring framework](https://getkinlead.com/ai-linkedin-lead-scoring-framework.md)
- [Lead groups and scoring](https://getkinlead.com/features/lead-groups-and-scoring.md)
- [AI lead scoring from website](https://getkinlead.com/ai-lead-scoring-from-website.md)

## Common questions

**Should I score leads based on their activity level?**

Activity is a signal of interest, not fit. Score for fit first to ensure they can buy, then use activity to decide when to send the message.

**How often should I update my scoring weights?**

Review your weights every month. If reply rates drop, your fit line is likely too low or your target title has shifted.

**What happens if a lead has the right title but the wrong company size?**

They will score in the medium range. If your product doesn't work for that size, make the company size weight high enough to push them below the fit line.

[Create a Kinlead account](https://getkinlead.com/signup) or [book a call](https://getkinlead.com/demo) to talk through pricing and setup.
