How to reply when a prospect asks for reviews or ratings

How to answer a LinkedIn sales prospect who asks for G2, Trustpilot or Capterra reviews, share the proof they want, and move the chat back to their problem without losing momentum.

Get started

Short answer

When a prospect asks for reviews on LinkedIn, send the exact page they asked for and ask one question about their current process in the same message. That keeps the proof in their hands and the conversation on their problem. If the review page is thin or mixed, name the gap and offer one specific case study or reference instead.

Why buyers ask for reviews mid-conversation

Someone who asks for your G2 or Trustpilot page on LinkedIn is usually close to a decision. They have seen your profile, read your headline and want one more check before they give you 30 minutes. The request is a risk check. They want to know that a company like theirs got a result with you.

Buyers ask for proof when they cannot judge fit from your profile alone. A review from someone with their job title or company size does more work than a list of features. Treat the request as a normal step in their buying process. If you send a link and stop there, the conversation moves to a browser tab. They may read two reviews, get pulled into a meeting and forget the chat. You lose the thread even when the reviews are good.

Your reply should satisfy the check and keep the conversation alive. Share the reviews and still make the next message about their problem. That is how you avoid a week of silence while they compare star ratings.

Weak reply

  • Here is our G2 page: [link]. Let me know if you have questions.
  • Send me your email and I will send a deck with reviews.
  • We have lots of reviews, what do you want to know?

Strong reply

  • Here is our G2 page: [link]. Most of the reviews mention [specific use case]. Is that the part you are checking?
  • That makes sense. Here is the page: [link]. Are you comparing us with your current tool or starting from scratch?
  • Here is the Trustpilot link: [link]. The reviews from [role] are the closest to your setup. What does your current process look like?

A three-part reply that keeps the thread moving

A useful reply has three jobs. It accepts the request, gives the exact link and asks one question that brings the conversation back to the buyer. Keep it short. A long message next to a review link looks defensive.

Use the same shape every time so you can reply fast from LinkedIn or your inbox. The question matters more than the wording. Ask about the buyer's current process, the trigger for looking or the part of the product they care about.

  1. 1

    Accept the request in one line

    Say something plain: 'That makes sense' or 'Good question, here is the page.' Do not apologize for your rating and do not oversell.

  2. 2

    Send the exact page

    Link to the review site page for your company, not the homepage. If you have a case study page that answers the same question, send one link, not three.

  3. 3

    Ask one question about their setup

    Pick a question that connects the reviews to their situation: 'Are you checking us against your current tool or starting from scratch?' or 'Which part of the workflow are you trying to fix first?'

Paste this job

That makes sense. Here is our [G2/Trustpilot/Capterra] page: [link]. The reviews from [role or company type] are the closest to your setup. Are you comparing us with your current tool or starting from scratch?

Examples that keep the thread moving

The reply should sound like a person wrote it. The link is the proof. The question is the reason to keep typing. The exchange below works when the prospect is already engaged.

Example

  1. Prospect

    Do you have any G2 reviews? I want to check before we talk.

  2. You

    That makes sense. Here is our G2 page: [link]. The reviews from operations leads are the closest to your setup. Are you replacing a tool or trying to fix a manual process?

  3. Prospect

    Manual process. We use a spreadsheet and it breaks every week.

  4. You

    That is the same trigger most of those reviewers mention. Do you have 15 minutes on Thursday to walk through the spreadsheet handoff?

  5. Prospect

    Thursday works.

The reply does not wait for the prospect to finish reading. It gives them a reason to answer while the page is open. If they care about the manual process, the review link stops being the center of the conversation.

Handling a low rating or missing reviews

Not every company has a perfect score or a full page of reviews. If your public profile is thin, do not ignore the request or invent proof. Answer the question, name the gap and offer something specific they can check.

Use one of the responses below depending on what you have. Keep the same structure: accept, give what exists, ask about their situation. Be useful. Do not debate review sites.

Low ratings

Scenario
Acknowledge the feedback and explain what changed.
Response strategy
We have some honest feedback on G2 about the mobile app. We fixed the sync issue in the last release. I can show you the current version if that is the part you are checking.

Missing reviews

Scenario
Send a relevant case study instead.
Response strategy
We are new to G2, so the page is thin. I can send a short case study from a 40-person agency that had the same handoff problem. Would that help?

No public proof

Scenario
Offer a small trial or a reference call.
Response strategy
We do not have public reviews yet. I can set up a 20-minute call with a customer in your industry or give you a trial workspace so you can test the workflow.

When they ask for customer references instead

Some buyers will skip the review site and ask for a customer reference. Treat that as a good sign. They want a conversation with someone who has the same problem, not another page to read.

Ask two questions before you promise anything: what they want to learn from the reference and which company size or industry is closest to theirs. Then send one reference that fits. Do not offer a list of names and make the buyer choose.

  • If you have a customer who will take a short call, ask them first and confirm the time window.
  • If you do not have a reference available, offer a case study with numbers from the same workflow. Say plainly that you cannot share the customer name.
  • If the buyer wants a reference before a demo, ask for a 15-minute call first so you can match them with the right customer.

Weak reference reply

  • Sure, I can send you a list of customers. Who do you want to talk to?
  • We have references but I need to check with my team.
  • Here is a case study. It is the same for everyone.

Strong reference reply

  • I can arrange a reference call. What do you want to learn from them: onboarding, reporting or the handoff from your current tool?
  • The closest customer is a 40-person agency with the same spreadsheet problem. I can ask if they have 15 minutes this week.
  • I cannot share names from that account, but I can send a one-page case study with the before and after numbers.

Doing this with Kinlead

Kinlead can keep your review link and the follow-up question in a sales playbook. When a prospect asks for ratings, the AI drafts a reply from the campaign goal, tone and your playbook. You can read and edit queued messages on the Actions page before they send, or set the campaign to hand the conversation to you at the first reply. That way the link goes out and you take over for the booking conversation.

Kinlead sends at a human pace, with one action every 5 minutes inside the daily limits and send window you set. See how campaigns and send windows work.

Frequently asked questions

Related

Get started with Kinlead

Prefer markdown? How to reply when a prospect asks for reviews or ratings.md