How to respond to requests for reviews on LinkedIn
Handle a prospect asking for reviews on LinkedIn by sending a third-party review link, guiding what to read, and pivoting back to their problem.
Get startedShort answer
Don't send a PDF or a list of names when a prospect asks for reviews. Send a link to a third-party review site, tell them what to read, then ask a question that brings the conversation back to the prospect's specific problem.
Why prospects ask for reviews
When a prospect asks for reviews, they usually aren't questioning your integrity. They're managing their own risk. If they buy a tool that fails, it looks bad to their boss. A review page lets them check the risk without asking you to be objective about your own product.
Your own testimonials or PDFs feel biased because you picked the best ones. Prospects know this. They want a neutral place where they can find honest critiques and see if the product fits their situation. That is why a link to a public review site often gets a faster reply than a polished case study.
The goal is to move from your word to a third party's word quickly. That lowers the trust barrier and lets you get back to discovery. If you make the prospect wait while you assemble proof, you give them time to lose interest.
What feels like proof to you
- A PDF of three happy customers
- A list of names who like the tool
- Saying 'Trust me, we have a great reputation'
What feels like proof to them
- A link to a G2 or Capterra profile
- A public review page with mixed ratings
- A third-party site they can scan on their own
What to send first
Send the review link in the same reply. Don't say you'll dig up a case study and come back tomorrow. The longer the gap, the more the prospect has to wonder why you hesitated.
Pick one page. A G2 profile, a Capterra page or a public review board is enough. Sending five links turns a simple request into homework and makes it harder for the prospect to start.
Give them one thing to look for. If you've been talking about reporting speed, point to the comments about reporting speed. If you've been talking about setup, point to that. You're not hiding the bad reviews. You're helping them read with the problem in mind.
Keep the message short. The link proves the product works. Your question keeps the conversation moving.
Example
- Prospect
This sounds interesting. Do you have any reviews or case studies I can look at?
- You
We have a few on G2. Here is the page: g2.com/products/acme/reviews. The comments about reporting speed are the ones closest to your setup. Does that match what you're seeing at Acme?
- Prospect
Yes, our current reports take forever. I'll take a look.
Paste this job
Thanks for asking. Here is our review page: [link]. The comments about [problem] are the ones closest to your setup. After you skim it, what would need to be true for [outcome] to be worth a short call?
How to pivot back to the sale
The biggest mistake on LinkedIn is letting a conversation turn into a research project. If the prospect disappears to read reviews for a few days, the deal cools off. You need a next step before they close the tab.
Acknowledge the request, send the link, then ask a question that puts them back in their own business. The question should be specific enough that they can't answer with 'looks good.' Ask about the cost of the problem, the team affected, or the deadline they're working against.
The pivot should connect the proof to their setup. If the review proves the product is reliable, the next step is proving it fits their workflow. That is a different question, and it belongs in a conversation, not a review page.
- 1
Acknowledge the request
Say you have a page they can check so they feel heard.
- 2
Send the external link
Paste the G2, Capterra or Trustpilot link in the same message.
- 3
Name the relevant theme
Point to the result or complaint in the reviews that matches their problem.
- 4
Ask a business question
Ask how that result would change their current workflow.
- 5
Offer a short next step
Propose a short call to map the reviews to their setup.
What to do when you have no reviews
If you're a founder or a new team without a G2 page, don't apologize. Apologizing makes the lack of reviews look like a lack of quality.
Offer a different kind of proof. A live demo of one feature is often more convincing than a written review because it happens in real time and they can ask questions. If you can't do live, send a short recording of the exact workflow they asked about.
If you have one strong customer who fits the prospect's profile, offer a reference call. Ask the customer first. Then tell the prospect what that customer uses and why the call is relevant. That offer is worth more than another PDF.
No review site
- Scenario
- Live feature demo
- Alternative proof
- I'll show you how we solved X for a similar company in a short demo.
Early stage
- Scenario
- Reference call
- Alternative proof
- I can put you in touch with our first customer who has the same setup.
Niche product
- Scenario
- Concrete workflow
- Alternative proof
- We helped a 40-person agency fix the same reporting gap with this workflow.
Never invent a review or borrow a customer story that doesn't fit. A prospect who checks will find the gap.
How to handle a request for customer names
Sometimes the ask is not 'send me a review link' but 'can I talk to a customer?' Treat that as a buying signal. They're close enough to check the risk.
Don't send a list of names. Ask what they want to learn from the call. Then pick one customer who has the same setup and has agreed to be a reference. One relevant call beats five names they have to chase.
Ask the customer for permission before you share their name. Tell them what the prospect wants to discuss and how long it should take. A reference call goes badly when the customer is surprised by the questions.
If you don't have a reference, say so. Offer a demo or a trial instead. Don't leave them waiting for a name you can't provide.
Weak answer
- I'll find someone and get back to you.
- Here are five names. Try any of them.
- Our customers are private, so I can't share anyone.
Strong answer
- What would you want to ask them about?
- I have one customer with your setup who is open to a short call.
- I don't have a reference for your exact case. I can show you the workflow live instead.
Following up after they read the reviews
Don't wait for them to come back with a verdict. When you send the link, set a light follow-up. 'I'll check in Thursday. If the reviews raise a question I can't answer, bring it to the call.' That gives you a reason to return without asking 'did you read it yet?'
When you follow up, ask what stood out. Not 'what did you think?' That question is too broad. Ask 'Did the comments about reporting speed match what you deal with?' or 'Was the setup complaint close to your situation?'
If they found a complaint that matters, answer it. If they found a complaint that doesn't apply, say why. Don't dismiss it. A prospect who brings up a bad review is still engaged. They're giving you a chance to respond.
Example
- Prospect
I read the reviews. A few people said setup took longer than expected.
- You
That's fair. The reviews from teams with a single workspace are the ones closest to you. The longer setups in those reviews were teams moving years of custom fields. How much custom data would you need to move?
- Prospect
Not much. We're starting clean.
- You
Then setup should be closer to the fast examples. Want to walk through the import on a short call?
Doing this with Kinlead
Kinlead sends replies from every campaign to one inbox and classifies them by intent, with interested replies first. A prospect asking for proof shows up with the interested replies, so you can answer while the request is fresh.
Use hand-off mode when you want to take over at the first reply. You keep the pivot question and the follow-up.
You can also put your review links and pivot questions in the campaign's sales playbook so the AI writes from the campaign goal, tone and your script. That keeps the message consistent. If you want to read every reply before it goes out, use hand-off mode. If you want to see the flow, book a demo.
Queued campaign messages can be read and edited on the Actions page before they send, and any campaign can be paused.
Frequently asked questions
Related
Get started with Kinlead
Prefer markdown? How to respond to requests for reviews on LinkedIn.md