How to respond when a prospect questions your experience
Handle questions about your business age or client list on LinkedIn without lying. Use the bridge technique to prove your expertise and close meetings.
Get startedShort answer
When a prospect asks how long you've been in business, the date is rarely the real question. They're weighing risk: whether hiring you will cost them a quarter, a budget or their manager's trust. Answer the date in one sentence, then spend the rest of your reply on the risk and on the experience you personally bring.
What the prospect is actually asking
A prospect who asks how long you've been in business is deciding whether to take a risk on you. The words that came out are about dates. What they're weighing is whether hiring you costs them something they can't afford to lose: a quarter of pipeline, a manager's trust, a system that half works today.
Those two questions have different answers. Answer the date question and you hand them a fact they can use to cross you off. Answer the risk question and you give them a reason to keep the call booked. The difference between those outcomes is usually one sentence of honesty followed by one sentence of substance.
The same applies to "who else have you worked with" and "are you an established firm". Both are stand-ins for something the buyer can't ask directly, which is whether they can defend choosing you to whoever signs off on the budget. Hand them something they can repeat in that room and the objection loses most of its weight.
What the prospect says
- How long have you been doing this?
- Who else in my industry have you worked with?
- Are you an established firm?
What they're weighing
- Will this waste a quarter I have to explain to my boss?
- Has someone with my exact setup already trusted you?
- Do you have a process, or are you figuring it out on my account?
Answer the question they asked in one sentence. Spend the rest of your reply on the risk behind it.
The bridge technique in three moves
The bridge is a structure, not a trick. You answer honestly in one sentence, then connect that answer to something the prospect cares about. Nothing gets hidden and nothing gets padded.
It works because buyers listen for defensiveness. A flat, short answer followed by a useful observation sounds like someone who has had this conversation before. A long answer with three justifications sounds like someone who hasn't.
Keep the whole thing under four sentences. If you need more room than that, you're explaining rather than answering, and the prospect can hear the difference.
- 1
Answer in one sentence
Say the number. "We started in March last year." "The company is 14 months old." Don't put "only" or "just" in front of it, and don't start justifying in the same breath.
- 2
Say what you did before this
Your company's age and your own experience are different numbers, and the second one is usually what they want. "Before this I spent six years running the same process in house at Northwind" gives them something to hold on to.
- 3
Land on their problem
Close with an observation about their situation that only someone who has done the work would make. One sentence, then a question. "Most teams your size lose deals at the scoring step, not at traffic. Is that where it's leaking for you?"
A reply you can send today
LinkedIn replies should be readable on a phone without scrolling. Three or four short sentences is enough to answer, reposition and ask a question. If your reply needs a second paragraph to explain itself, cut the explanation rather than the honesty.
Here's the shape of a real exchange. The prospect tested the founder with a risk question and got a straight answer back, plus something useful.
Example
- Prospect
How long has your agency been running? I've been burned by new vendors before.
- You
We started 14 months ago. Before that I ran paid social in house at Northwind for six years, which is where I learned that most lead gen fails at scoring, not at traffic.
- Prospect
Scoring is exactly where we're stuck.
- You
Then the first thing I'd look at is how you define a qualified lead before any spend goes out. Happy to walk through what that looked like at Northwind. Tuesday or Thursday?
Paste this job
Thanks for asking. We started {month and year}. Before that I spent {number} years doing {specific work} at {company}, which is where I learned that {specific failure mode}.
Quick question on your side: is {observation about their setup} still the bottleneck, or has that moved?When they ask who else you've worked with
This one gets harder the newer you are, because the honest answer is short. Don't borrow logos from an employer or from clients that belonged to your old company without saying whose work it was. Buyers check, and being caught stretching a client list costs more than not having one.
What you can do instead is offer a smaller version of the thing they're worried about. A scoped first phase, a paid pilot, a walkthrough of the method you'd use. The goal is to shrink the decision from "bet on this company" to "try this process on one problem".
A pilot needs a specific end date and a specific outcome, or it reads as a discount. "Four weeks, one lead scoring rebuild, you keep the documentation either way" is a pilot. "Let's just get started and see" is not.
A list of past clients
- What they ask for
- Beta partner terms on the first project
- What to offer instead
- They get a result worth talking about, you get a reference you can use later
Company logos
- What they ask for
- A walkthrough of the method you ran at your last job
- What to offer instead
- They're buying the process, so show the process rather than the badge
Testimonials
- What they ask for
- A small paid pilot with a fixed end date
- What to offer instead
- It limits their exposure without asking them to trust you first
When they ask for proof you don't have
Some prospects want three case studies from their exact industry before they'll talk. Sometimes that's a real requirement from their procurement process and sometimes it's a polite exit. You can't tell which from the message, so answer once with something concrete and watch what comes back.
If they go quiet after your honest answer, send one follow-up with something new in it, then move on. Chasing a prospect who needed you to be three years older is a bad use of a week.
- A live walkthrough: open their site or their pipeline with them on a call and map the first three steps you'd change.
- A named failure: describe a specific way the work goes wrong in their industry and what you did about it the last time you saw it.
- A reference from your previous role, with permission, as long as you're clear the work happened inside a company rather than at your agency.
- A paid pilot with a written summary of what you found, so the value survives even if they don't continue.
One clear piece of proof beats five vague assurances. If they want more than you have, say so and offer the pilot instead of talking around it.
Doing this with Kinlead
You can put your answer to the credibility question into the sales playbook, which is your own script that the AI writes from. Set the campaign goal and tone, paste in how you want the age question handled, and the messages and follow-ups follow that pattern.
Credibility questions usually need you rather than a template, so set the campaign to hand the conversation over at the first reply. Queued messages and follow-ups can be read and edited on the Actions page before they send, and replies from every campaign land in one inbox with interested ones first. You can book a demo to see how a playbook shapes the opening message.
If you want to answer the experience question yourself every time, use hand-off mode rather than an AI reply mode.
Frequently asked questions
Related
Get started with Kinlead
Prefer markdown? How to respond when a prospect questions your experience.md