How to reply when a prospect asks you to call them
Stop phone tag and ghosting on LinkedIn. Learn how to turn a vague 'just call me' request into a firm calendar invitation that actually happens.
Get startedShort answer
A prospect who says 'just call me' has agreed to talk but hasn't agreed to a time. Reply with two specific slots in your next message, then send the calendar invite before they ask for it so the call lands on their calendar instead of in a chat window.
Why 'just call me' rarely turns into a call
A reply that says 'just give me a call' looks like a green light. Most of the time it's a polite way to close the conversation without opening a calendar. The person means it when they type it, then the afternoon happens and it's gone.
The failure is easy to predict. You call the next day at a time that suits you. They're in a meeting, or driving, or on another call. You leave a voicemail. They don't listen to it because the number isn't saved. Two days later the thread is cold and you're weighing whether a third follow-up looks desperate.
The fix is to move the agreement from an intention to an event. Ask for a specific time in your next message, then put it on their calendar. Asking for a time is normal, and it's the only way to make sure the slot they offered gets used.
There's a second reason to do it. A prospect who agrees to a time and then sees an invite has made a small commitment in writing. That commitment is what gets them on the call.
Just call me approach
- You call sometime tomorrow and hope
- They're in a meeting, so you leave a voicemail
- The voicemail goes unheard because they don't know the number
- You follow up twice and hear nothing
Firm time approach
- You reply with two specific times
- They pick one and it goes on their calendar
- The invite reminds them an hour before
- The call happens and you talk to a live person
What to say in your first reply
Agree first, then narrow. Two short sentences do the work: one accepts the call, the other asks them to choose between two times. Anything longer reads like a pitch and gives them a reason to delay.
Offer two options instead of asking when they're free. 'When works for you' gets you 'sometime next week', which is the same problem with a friendlier tone. 'Does 10am or 2pm work better' is a question with two answers, and both of them are a meeting.
Mention that your own day is booked. It gives them a reason to pick a slot instead of leaving it open, and it makes the call feel like part of your schedule rather than something you're sitting by the phone for. Say it in one clause and move on. Long explanations about how busy you are sound like an excuse.
Example
- Prospect
Just give me a call tomorrow.
- You
Will do. I'm in meetings most of the morning, so I'd rather not catch you at a bad time. Does 10am or 2pm suit you better?
- Prospect
10am is fine.
- You
Great. Sending an invite now so it's on your calendar. Talk tomorrow at 10.
When they won't pick a time
'I'm free all afternoon' or 'just try me whenever' is the weakest version of yes. Nothing is anchored, so nothing has to happen. The afternoon fills with other things and your call slides to the bottom of it.
Narrow the window instead of repeating the question. Offer a block rather than an hour: 'between 9 and 10' or 'right after 4'. Then say why the slot matters. 'I want your account open while we talk' gives them a reason to protect the time.
If they still won't choose, choose for them. Send the invite for the most likely window and tell them you've done it so they don't have to remember. Most people accept a time that's already been picked, and the ones who can't will say so.
- 1
Offer two blocks, not two hours
Say 'between 9 and 10, or after 4' so they only have to pick a part of the day. A block is easier to agree to than an exact minute.
- 2
Give the slot a reason
Tell them what you'll have ready, such as their site notes or a competitor example, so the call sounds worth protecting against other meetings.
- 3
Send the invite anyway
Pick the window that fits their timezone and message them that it's booked. If it clashes they'll tell you, and you still have a time to work with.
What goes in the calendar invite
The invite is the record of the agreement. If it isn't on their calendar, the call is a sentence in a chat window they'll scroll past on their phone.
Write it so it works on its own. Someone opening it cold should see who's calling, what it's about, and the number to reach. Don't make them go back to LinkedIn to find your details.
Keep the title plain. 'Discovery call' means nothing to a warehouse manager. Their name, your company and the topic is enough, and it makes the invite look like a normal meeting rather than a sales event.
Title
- Invite element
- Sales call
- Weak
- Sarah (Northwind) / John (Acme), delivery delays
Location
- Invite element
- TBD
- Weak
- Your mobile number, so it's tappable on a phone
Description
- Invite element
- Left blank
- Weak
- Short call about the Q3 delivery backlog and the two options your team is weighing.
Attendees
- Invite element
- Prospect only, no context
- Weak
- Both of you, with a line saying who dials
Put your number in the location field of the invite, not just the notes. On a phone it becomes a tap-to-call link, and that's the difference between a call that starts on time and one that starts with an apology.
What to do when they miss the call
People miss calls. One missed call isn't a lost deal, but three in a row is. Call once at the agreed time, let it ring out, and don't redial.
Send one message within ten minutes with a new specific time in it. Not 'let me know when you're free'. A time. 'Mornings are chaos, I get it. Does 3pm today or 9am tomorrow work?'
If they miss the second one, the interest was soft. Put them back into a normal follow-up sequence and stop treating the call as agreed. Two no-shows tells you where you are in their week.
Paste this job
Hi Sarah, missed you at 10. Mornings are busy, I get it. I can do 2pm today or 9:30 tomorrow, whichever is easier. If neither works, send me a time and I'll take it.
Doing this with Kinlead
Kinlead can answer the reply for you. A campaign can be set to let the AI reply until a meeting is booked using your scheduling link, so a 'just call me' message comes back with a booking instead of sitting in your inbox until you notice it. Replies from every campaign land in one inbox, sorted by intent, and you get an email when someone replies.
If you'd rather take the conversation yourself at the first reply, choose hand-off mode. The AI writes the outreach and stops as soon as someone answers. Both modes are set per campaign, and you can read and edit queued messages before they send. The booking side is covered on demo booking.
Frequently asked questions
Related
Get started with Kinlead
Prefer markdown? How to reply when a prospect asks you to call them.md