How to message a prospect after a lost deal
Learn how to follow up with lost prospects on LinkedIn using low-pressure check-ins that target the gap between a competitor's promise and their delivery.
Get startedShort answer
Wait until the new vendor's setup phase is underway, then send a short message asking whether the specific problem they hired that vendor to fix is actually gone. Don't ask for the business back in the first message.
When to reach back out
It's easy to let a lost deal sit. The contract gets signed somewhere else, the stage flips to closed lost, and nobody looks at it again until renewal season. By then the buyer has either settled in or is too worn down by the switch to consider another one.
The better window is earlier, while the new tool is still being set up. That's when the gap between the sales demo and the daily reality shows up. Ask whether the problem they hired the other vendor to fix is actually gone. Don't ask for the business back.
Pick the moment from what they told you during the deal. If implementation speed was the thing they cared about, check in around the time implementation should be finishing. If reporting was the thing, wait until their first quarter close.
If you never got a clear reason for the loss, ask. A short message to the person who ran the evaluation often gets a straight answer months later, and that answer tells you which window to use.
30 days in
- When
- Whether setup is going as smoothly as the demo suggested
- What you're checking
- Ask if the tool is where they expected it to be by now
90 days in
- When
- Whether the main pain point is still there
- What you're checking
- Ask if the manual work has crept back in
6 months in
- When
- Whether the attention they got during the sale has dropped off
- What you're checking
- Ask who they go to now when something breaks
A month before renewal
- When
- Whether they're reviewing the contract
- What you're checking
- Ask if they're looking at alternatives this cycle
The low-pressure framework
You're writing from behind. They already picked someone else, and a pushy message just confirms the choice. So the message shouldn't ask for a meeting, a demo or a call. It should ask about their current state.
Name the specific problem they had. Say what usually happens after a fix like that. Then ask one question about whether it's holding. No pitch and no calendar link.
Keep it to two or three sentences. Long messages read like a proposal, and a proposal is the thing they already turned down.
Pushy or vague
- I'm checking in to see if you're unhappy with the other vendor yet.
- Do you have any updates on your needs for this quarter?
- Just wondering if you've reconsidered our proposal from last year.
Specific and low pressure
- I remember manual data entry was eating your team's Fridays. Is that actually solved now, or has it crept back?
- The first 90 days of a setup like that are usually the roughest. Is the tool doing what you hoped for your routing?
- We rebuilt the reporting piece we talked about. Not sure it's relevant anymore, but happy to send the two-minute version if it is.
Message templates for different scenarios
Write around the pain point they described during the original deal, not around your product. If you can quote their own words back to them, do it.
These three cover the common cases. Change the bracketed parts to what actually happened.
The exchange further down is what a good one looks like. The first message doesn't mention your product at all, and the second one only offers something after the buyer admits a gap.
Example
- You
Hi Sarah, you went with Acme back in March. Setups like that usually take longer than the demo suggests. Is yours where you expected it to be by now?
- Prospect
Not really. We're still routing leads by hand three months in.
- You
That gap shows up when the routing rules have to be rebuilt from scratch. If it's useful, I can show you how we handle it without the rebuild. No pressure either way.
Paste this job
Template 1: the problem came back Hi [Name], we spoke last year about [specific problem]. Fixes like that usually hold for a few months before the manual work creeps back in. Is it still under control, or is it a headache again? Template 2: the setup is dragging Hi [Name], you went with [vendor] back in [month]. Setups like that often take longer than the demo suggests. Is yours where you expected it to be by now? Template 3: the team changed Hi [Name], I worked with [previous person] on [project] before they moved on. You've inherited [tool] since then. Curious whether it fits how your team works now, or whether you're stuck with it.
What to write when you're not connected yet
If the deal ended without a connection, you get one note, and LinkedIn caps connection notes under 200 characters. That's roughly two sentences, so every word has to carry.
Don't spend the note reintroducing yourself or your company. Spend it showing you remember their situation. A note that could have been sent to anyone gets ignored.
Generic note
- Hi Sarah, I'd like to connect and stay in touch about future opportunities.
- Hi Sarah, I saw you're a VP of Sales and thought we should connect.
Note that proves you remember
- Hi Sarah, we spoke in March about lead routing. Curious how the new setup is holding up. Happy to compare notes.
- Hi Sarah, you mentioned manual routing was costing your team a day a week. Did the new tool fix that?
Handling the response
Replies land in a few buckets, and each needs a different move. None of them involve listing features or arguing with the choice they made.
The one thing that loses the deal permanently is gloating. If they admit the other tool isn't working, don't say you told them so. Ask one more question and let them get there themselves.
Speed matters less than you'd think. The buyer is mid-implementation and busy. Answering within a day is fine.
It's going fine
- What they say
- They're not ready to talk, and pushing now costs you the relationship
- What it means
- Say you're glad, ask about one specific gap, then ask to check in before renewal
We're still setting it up
- What they say
- The window is open
- What it means
- Ask what's taking the longest and offer to compare notes. No demo yet
Honestly it's not working
- What they say
- They're already thinking about switching
- What it means
- Ask what they'd need to see to consider a change, then send one thing
No reply
- What they say
- The timing is wrong or the message missed
- What it means
- Wait, then try a different angle once. Two follow-ups at most
Never criticise the competitor by name. Describe the limitation in the process or the setup, not the company.
Staying in their orbit until renewal
Most lost deals don't come back on the first message. They come back when something breaks, and the person who stayed in touch politely is the one who gets the call.
That means a light touch every few months with something useful: a change in your product that touches their problem, or a question about how their team handles something.
Keep a note of what they said when they turned you down. The reason they gave is usually the thing that eventually breaks, and quoting it back six months later shows you were listening.
- 1
Put the renewal date in your calendar
Ask when the contract renews, or estimate from when they signed. Set a reminder for three months before.
- 2
Write down the specific gap
Note the one thing you know the other tool handles badly. That's the thread you pull when you come back.
- 3
Send something useful every quarter
One short message with something they can use, no ask attached. A couple of sentences is enough.
- 4
Reopen the conversation before renewal
Three months out, ask whether they're reviewing the contract. That's when switching is a real option rather than a hassle.
Doing this with Kinlead
You can keep lost deals in a lead group by importing a CSV of LinkedIn profile URLs, then point a campaign at that group. A sales playbook sets the tone so the messages stay low pressure instead of turning into a pitch.
Set the campaign to hand the conversation to you at the first reply. Lost deals need judgement, and you want to read the answer yourself. Queued messages can be read and edited on the Actions page before they send, which is where you check that the pain point in the message is the one they actually described.
Frequently asked questions
Related
Get started with Kinlead
Prefer markdown? How to message a prospect after a lost deal.md